GemFind RingBuilder vs Pencil
GemFind RingBuilder lets a shopper pair a setting from a supplier catalog with a diamond from a supplier feed. Pencil lets a shopper design the ring itself, as a parametric CAD model.
One sells what a supplier already makes. The other makes what your customer asks for.
RingBuilder is a static builder. The shopper picks a setting, picks a diamond and checks out. There is no CAD model behind the ring, so nothing about the design can change beyond the options the catalog lists.
It is made by GemFind, a digital marketing and web design agency for jewelers that also sells apps. On Shopify it costs $295 a month.
GemFind RingBuilder and Pencil comparison
| GemFind RingBuilder | Pencil |
| Type of builder | Static. Pick a setting, then pick a diamond | Dynamic. The shopper designs the ring |
| Technology | A catalog of supplier products | Parametric CAD |
| Where the designs come from | Supplier catalogs. Your own settings as images in Custom RingBuilder | Pencil's library and your own designs |
| How it differs from store to store | Standard version has the same supplier settings and feeds on every site | Your designs, on your site only |
| What the shopper can change | Setting, metal and diamond, from the options listed | Every design attribute possible |
| Stones and diamonds | Feed diamonds. Moissanite and other gemstones are not supported on Shopify | Live diamond feeds and more than 40 stone types |
| What the shopper sees | Catalog media for the setting, including video | Live 3D of the actual design |
| Price shown | Supplier prices with your markup rules | The exact price, calculated from the design |
| Production file | None mentioned | Ready for every design |
| Last feature announcement | Custom RingBuilder, May 2025, that we could find | New features twice a week |
| Who makes it | A digital marketing and web design agency | A jewelry CAD company |
| Price | $295 a month on Shopify, $345 with try-on | Free to start. $199 a month for Pencil Shop |
RingBuilder is a static builder
RingBuilder works in two steps. The shopper chooses a setting, then chooses a diamond to go in it. GemFind describes the options as carat, metal and setting.
The settings are products from supplier catalogs. GemFind's pages name Overnight Mountings as the source of pre-loaded settings. The diamonds come from feeds such as IDEX, RapNet, Polygon and Nivoda, with your markup applied.
GemFind's Shopify listing says the app lets you "showcase and sell virtual rings". Shopify lists it under dropshipping and sourcing. That is an accurate description. RingBuilder is a way to sell inventory you do not hold.
A static builder limits you to the list. If a customer wants the band a little wider, the head a little lower or a design that is not in the catalog, the builder has no answer.
GemFind also offers Custom RingBuilder, announced in May 2025, which adds the option to load your own settings from your own images. That makes the list longer. Each entry is still a finished product with no model behind it.
There is no CAD in RingBuilder
GemFind's RingBuilder pages for Shopify and WordPress do not mention CAD, a 3D model or a production file. The WordPress plugin description lists settings, diamonds and embedded video. We found no claim that RingBuilder creates a design file of any kind.
GemFind knows the difference. Its own guide to choosing a ring builder app describes parametric CAD and production-ready CAD files as features of advanced builders. The guide does not say that RingBuilder has them.
Without a model, a ring has no adjustable geometry. The shopper is choosing between finished products, and the price is the supplier's price plus your markup.
You sell what the supplier makes
A catalog builder ties your range to someone else's range. With the standard RingBuilder, every jeweler using the same supplier feed shows the same settings, and the only thing that differs is the markup.
The limits are stated on the listing. GemFind's Shopify listing says moissanite and other gemstones are not supported. The WordPress plugin needs a GemFind JewelCloud dealer account before it shows any inventory.
If your business is your own designs, a builder that can only show a supplier's designs works against you.
The same builder on every website
RingBuilder can be styled to match your website. What is inside the standard version is the same for everyone. Every jeweler who installs it gets the same steps, the same supplier settings and the same diamond feeds. Your own settings and your own branding are the Custom RingBuilder option.
A shopper who compares three stores running RingBuilder sees the same rings three times, at three markups. That leaves you nothing to differentiate on except price.
Your designs, your proportions and your style are not in the builder, because the builder can only show what the supplier supplies. In Pencil, the builder holds your designs, and no other store has them unless you choose to share them.
RingBuilder is built by a marketing agency
GemFind's homepage calls the company "the most experienced digital marketing agency in the jewelry industry". Its services are Shopify website design, SEO, paid ads, social media and email marketing. RingBuilder is one of several apps it sells alongside those services.
The Shopify listing for RingBuilder shows the same priorities. Its feature list includes Shopify website development, digital marketing and POS integration, which are GemFind services and not features of the app.
GemFind does employ developers. Its team page lists 20 people, and most of the roles are in sales, marketing, account management and support.
Pencil is a software company and nothing else. We build a CAD engine, and we ran a jewelry manufacturing business with our own CAD team before we started.
A newer interface on the same model
GemFind first announced Ring Builder in February 2010. Since then we could find three feature announcements for it: a new version in February 2011, virtual try-on in November 2021 and Custom RingBuilder in May 2025.
That is the most recent one, about 18 months ago. The plugins still receive maintenance updates, and the WordPress version has a newer version 2 interface.
The product underneath is the same one from 2010. RingBuilder's page still calls it "the first and only responsive ring designer" and still promotes Facebook integration. The Shopify app launched in October 2020 and has two reviews, both from April 2021.
A new interface does not change what the builder can do. It is still a setting and a diamond from a list. Pencil publishes new features twice a week.
What Pencil does instead
Pencil is a dynamic design builder. Every ring is a parametric CAD model, so the shopper can change the stone, the band width, the prongs and the metal, and the model updates.
The same model drives everything else.
The customer sees it in live 3D on your website.
The price is calculated from it and updates with every change.
The production file is ready when they order, with no CAD rebuild.
Lead capture collects the shopper's details as they design, and the Pencil API sends each lead to your CRM.
Pencil is a sales platform as well as a design tool. Lead capture is built into every builder. The API connects your leads and designs to your CRM. A full analytics platform shows how shoppers use your builders.
The designs are yours. You build them once in Pencil, or have the AI designer build them from a conversation, and they are not shared with every other jeweler on the same feed.
You do not give up diamond inventory to get this. Pencil connects to live diamond feeds, and it supports more than 40 stone types, including moissanite and colored gemstones.
Pencil is free to start designing. Pencil Shop adds ring, pendant and nameplate builders for your website for $199 a month, with a 7-day free trial.
Frequently asked questions
Is GemFind RingBuilder CAD software?
No. RingBuilder pairs settings from supplier catalogs with diamonds from supplier feeds. Its product pages do not mention CAD, a 3D model or a production file.
Can shoppers customize a ring in GemFind RingBuilder?
They can choose a setting, a metal and a diamond from the options listed. They cannot change the dimensions of a design or create one that is not in the catalog.
Does GemFind RingBuilder support moissanite and colored gemstones?
The Shopify listing says moissanite and other gemstones are not supported. Pencil supports more than 40 stone types.
How much does GemFind RingBuilder cost?
On Shopify it is $295 a month, or $345 a month with virtual try-on, with a 7-day free trial. GemFind does not publish prices for the WordPress and Magento versions on its product pages.
Who makes GemFind RingBuilder?
GemFind Digital Solutions, a digital marketing and web design agency for the jewelry industry, founded in 1999 and based in Newport Beach, California.
What is the best alternative to GemFind RingBuilder?
For jewelers who sell their own designs, Pencil. It is a dynamic design builder on parametric CAD, with exact live pricing and a production file for every order.
